Thursday, November 26, 2009

McKinsey proposes FART framework to tackle employee unrest

Mumbai. McKinsey and Company, the global leaders in management consultancy services, have proposed a new framework for companies dealing with employee unrest arising out of unfriendly and unpopular business decisions. The framework, published in the visitor edition of The McKinsey Quarterly, advocates a four-pronged strategy called FART to deal with the dissatisfaction among employees if and when they fail to appreciate prudent business decisions like cost-cutting measures.

FART stands for Feed, Affect, Relegate, and Terminate – four different approaches that a company should take based on mix of two parameters – existing ‘Employee Mindset’ and the ‘Cash Status’ of the company. The McKinsey Quarterly report elaborates each of these four approaches of the FART framework with several exhibits to back up the study.

The visual representation of the framework has been called McFart, but this could potentially cause a legal battle over copyright between McKinsey and McDonalds
The visual representation of the framework has been called McFart, but this could potentially cause a legal battle over copyright between McKinsey and McDonalds

“If the company has a bit of cash and the employees’ mindset is still to turn hostile, the company should ‘feed’ the employees to stop them from turning hostile. The best way to ‘feed’ is to give some freebies like season gifts, personalized cakes on birthdays, shopping coupons, free pizzas during working hours, etc.” the report explained the ‘feed’ approach of the FART framework.

In case employees’ mood has turned a bit hostile and some of them are demanding explanations about issues such as scrapping of bonuses and other benefits, the FART framework suggests ‘affect’ approach for companies with surplus cash. ‘Affect’ approach requires the company to affect i.e. pretend taking some proactive steps for employee welfare.

“The company could initiate a pretentious performance appraisal process to quell the employee unrest. Other steps could involve sending the employees a feedback form, or inviting employees for a one-to-one interview with HR executives, etc. Such steps mollify the hostile mood of the employees, giving them a hope about future, but these steps should be taken only when the company has some cash to meet the expenses associated with these affected steps.” the report elaborated.

If a company doesn’t enjoy the luxury of surplus cash and is running into losses, the FART framework advocates ‘relegate’ approach, but only if the employees are in a friendly mindset, which is rare in normal course. The approach involves taking steps like lowering the compensation packages and demoting the employees. The report describes the ‘relegate’ approach as being a transient approach as it usually ends up changing the employee mindset from friendly to hostile, leaving the company to adopt the forth and the final approach – terminate.

“If the company is running into losses and employees have turned hostile, the best approach is to ‘terminate’ i.e. fire the employees.” the report concluded the FART framework, which has been well received by various HR professionals across companies.


IndiaAnalytics said...

Very Informative,Indeed a new approach to tackle the current scenario.
Keep writing!!!

paulvin matt said...

Paulvin Mathew

I know it is not the place to ask this question but i feel i have to. Either i get a reply from you which might help me to full fill my dreams.For a fresher who is very much interested to join Siemens automation what he should do?. I Learning German just to be part of this company . I am planning to do master's program in Robotics and Automation from Germany so i might get a chance to do internship at Siemens for 6 months.What should be done to get a chance to attend a interview for Siemens ? . I can't find a mail id of you from linkedin, that's why writing over here.It won't be saved to your page unless and until you gave the permission so this post may not be creating any problem for you. My intention is just to get a guidance from you Sir. I like to work for a automation company, am too much addicted to this field . I am not at all interested to work in IT, already this is my 6th month without a job . I am waiting for just an interview from any automation company , small or large.But until now it is "0", all i need is a chance to attend an interview. sorry for bothering you, just consider it as a frustration of a job hunter